Shattering the Frame: Why Perfect Composition Is Overrated

Flume – Music Midtown ‘23, Atlanta

Matty Healy of The 1975 – Music Midtown ‘23, Atlanta

Introduction

In photography, the word "composition" is akin to a sacred scripture — hallowed guidelines that have canonized what an image should aspire to. Rule of Thirds, Leading Lines, Patterns, and Symmetry are the cornerstones upon which countless photographers build their craft. But what if adhering to these principles too religiously was the shackle that kept your creativity in chains?

What Makes a Good Composition?

Let's get right to the heart of the matter. A good photo, at its most distilled essence, is contingent on balance, intrigue, and storytelling. It is a snapshot that captures and invokes both feeling and meaning. It's not the rigid adherence to rules that makes a photograph stand out but rather the evocative tale that the visual ensemble plays out.

Don't set your traditional composition guidelines ablaze just yet; they are fundamentals for a reason. The Rule of Thirds, for instance, nudges us towards a harmonic distribution of what I like to refer to as visual weight. Leading Lines act as the audience's guide, drawing the gaze through the narrative you've framed. Patterns and Symmetry evoke a sense of order, a visual rhythm that pleases the eye.

A. Jay Popoff of Lit – Smith’s Olde Bar, Atlanta

The Gifts of Imperfection

But here's where the plot thickens, and the frame shatters – true visual storytelling often lies in the subtle rebellion against these very guidelines. I’d argue that it's in the unbalanced compositions that tension and drama are born. It's in the broken patterns where we find the human element and the disregarded symmetry where we encounter the rawness of reality. Innovation in art has never arisen from playing it by the book; instead, it's the mavericks, the pioneers, the audacious explorers of the frame who have etched their names in the annals of image-making history.

At its core, photography is about capturing a moment, an emotion, a slice of the human experience. When was the last time life played out in neatly cropped thirds or offered you leading lines to show you the way? The most compelling stories embrace the messiness of life, inviting the viewer to fill in the gaps, to partake in the scene, to feel rather than to simply view.

B*tch, Don’t Kill My Vibe

Throughout my experiences looking through the viewfinder, I've found that the moments that resonate the most are those captured in the thrall of the scene and not when my mind was handcuffed to the gridlines on my camera. Although I appreciate the foundation, you’d be amazed at what you can capture when you break away and allow the scene to breathe.

Adam Russell of Story of the Year – The Masquerade, Atlanta

Final Thoughts

So, here's your permission slip to experiment, play with shadows, let subjects drift away from the center of the frame, and appreciate the beauty within the chaos. Color outside the lines, and you might find a masterpiece in the margins.

While composition guidelines provide a strong starting point, they are just that — starting points. Artistic rules can stifle creativity if adhered to too dogmatically. A genuinely memorable photograph brings a fresh perspective, tells an engaging story, and rings with the echo of authentic emotion. Sometimes, the pictures that break the rules are the ones we can't look away from — the ones that truly capture the imperfect beauty of our world and echo the rebellion of life itself.

In sum, trust your instincts. Photography is a form of expression, not perfection! By all means, learn the rules, understand them, even master them — and then choose when to let them go. The world is replete with photographs that tick all the boxes; dare to deliver ones that speak to the soul instead.

Previous
Previous

PHOTOS: Baby Jungle Portrait Session at Cam Kirk Studios in Atlanta, GA

Next
Next

PHOTOS: Lit at Smith’s Olde Bar in Atlanta, Georgia